Leverage, the mechanism to do more with less, has to factor quality, argues the eleven-page Market Insights this month from the $23 billion hedge funds firm DE Shaw & Co.
Investment managers, investors and regulators are often not on the same
page in measuring leverage, according to the world's eighth biggest hedge funds manager. It highlights six factors to estimate the quality of a portfolio's leverage.
1. Term: Matching longer duration assets, especially illiquid ones, with longer-term liabilities.
2. Haircut: If lower, reduces counterparty risk and frees capital to be productively deployed elsewhere.
3. Haircut stability: Constant as against 'variables'. Provisions, such as VaR, are analogous to rating triggers. Example - AIG in 2008.
4. Counterparty's stability: A partner less likely to default, violate contract terms or act aggressively in times of stress. More willing to work with borrowers on new investment initiatives.
5. Valuation: A fair mechanism of pricing the financed asset, and including provisions for margin dispute resolution such as third-party arbitration.
6. Cost: Less than the expected return enhancement.
The principles of managing assets also apply to managing a portfolio of liabilities. Most notably -
a. Diversification: In terms of counterparties, assets and financing structure.
b. Term structuring: A longer or 'termed out' financing is costlier than the short-term option. This, however, could be viewed as an insurance premium against protection from cataclysmic losses if a crisis occurs.
c. Stress testing: By running various forms of liquidation scenarios.
The report suggests factoring the derivative exposure -- not accounted on the balance sheet as per US GAAP -- when calculating leverage. On the other side, derivative-adjusted leverage does not necessarily indicate the amount of financing. In the case of pair trade or interest-rate swaps, the notional value and nominal leverage are higher than the actual risk involved.
The conclusion: though it may increase the complexity of the discussions, both managers and investors stand to benefit from comprehensive dialogues on the quality of leverage.
Recent Comments